Best garage roof replacement material?

Looking to replace ours soon and there’s a lot of options out there. Felt, rubber, sheets? What do you recommend?

Asked by Greg on 30th Sep 2025
Expert Trade Answers
"I reccomend edpm rubber lasts a lot longer and more durable ."
Answered on 7th Oct 2025 - Member since Jul 2021 - report
"Sheets would a quick cheaper option all depends what it is you actually have on now and if it is rotted etc if so would rip off."
Answered on 1st Oct 2025 - Member since Aug 2025 - report
"As a roofer with many years experience in all different flat roofing systems , i would still recommend traditional felt. if done correctly it should easily last thirty plus years.

On my own house its what i would use over any of the newer cold applied roof coverings."
Answered on 9th Oct 2025 - Member since Oct 2025 - report
"Single ply membrane will give you the best lifespan, does cost a little more but worth it in the long run."
Answered on 2nd Oct 2025 - Member since Jul 2023 - report
"I think your first choice is a Fiberglass, even if you don't rely on it for it’s felt"
Answered on 6th Nov 2025 - Member since Nov 2025 - report
"For a garage I would say rubber or felt. Depending on the roof."
Answered on 4th Oct 2025 - Member since Apr 2025 - report
"I would recommend torch on felt as a cheaper option will last about 15-20 years, if done correctly"
Answered on 4th Oct 2025 - Member since Dec 2024 - report
Find Tradespeople, compare up to 3 quotes!
It's FREE and there are no obligations
Ask a Trade
Got a question that only a tradesperson can answer? We have thousands of trades ready to answer any question you may have.
Ask your question
Ask a Trade

Are you looking for advice on a DIY project or have a question for our tradespeople?

We'll email your question to tradespeople who are skilled in your chosen category.

Your question will be made public - please do not include any personal details.

{{ first(ask.errors)[0] }}

By continuing you agree to the Community Guidelines.

Report Content

{{ first(reportForm.errors) }}

Thank you

Your report has been created and will be investigated shortly.

Ready to get a price for your home improvement project?
Get started

Over 1 million homeowners and over 50,000 tradespeople
use MyJobQuote nationwide each year