Replacing a cracked shower tray

I have a cracked shower tray in small en-suite. Is it possible to replace this without dismantling the surrounding cubicle?

Asked by Chris on 5th Oct 2026
Expert Trade Answers
"Hi Chris — the short answer is: it can be done, but it's tight! If the cubicle panels are screwed together rather than siliconed tight against the walls, there's a slim chance we can carefully remove just one side panel, swap the tray, and put it back. But more often than not, the panels overlap or are fixed in such a way that they need to come off to get the old tray out and the new one in.

The good news: even if we do need to remove the screens, it's usually only one or two panels, not the whole enclosure. And we can reseal everything so it looks and feels brand new. Definitely worth getting someone to take a quick look first — every setup is a bit different!"
Answered on 20th Oct 2026 - Member since Jul 2026 -
"Hi, yes, it may be possible to replace the shower tray without completely dismantling the surrounding cubicle. It will depend on how the tray and shower enclosure have been fitted and how much access there is.
I’d need to have a look first to see how it’s been installed. If possible, I’ll aim to keep the existing cubicle and surrounding areas intact to avoid any unnecessary work or damage, but I’ll let you know what’s involved before starting."
Answered on 5th Oct 2026 - Member since Mar 2022 -
"It depends. Is the tray cracked due to impact damage or because the floor is moving. If you want the job done right because the floor is sagging I would lift the tray and beef up the floor below so it is solid and then install a new solid tray not a flimsy plastic one. Assuming the floor is wooden and not concrete. If the cubicle is panels going into a frame on the wall then the panels can be removed without disturbing the frame or tiling. Pictures or a viewing would help clarify the solutions available to you. Taking shortcuts may cut cost but will defer problems until a later date."
Answered on 5th Oct 2026 - Member since Sep 2022 -
"No it is not possible to replace your shower try without removing the shower cubical,as it will be attached to the tray with silicon. Also I will need to lift it up off the floor to replace but as of removing the cubical. That's not a big job to remove and replace after the shower tray has been replaced. I would quote you about £200 but I would like to have a look to asses the job first to give you an exact price."
Answered on 5th Oct 2026 - Member since Jul 2026 -
"You would have to take the cubicle out first they usually don’t go back in the same and try to reseal them better with new cubicle aswell"
Answered on 6th Oct 2026 - Member since Sep 2026 -
"No, it is generally not possible to replace a cracked shower tray without at least partially dismantling or disturbing the surrounding cubicle.
Because of how showers are constructed to be watertight, the glass enclosure, wall tiling or cladding, and internal plumbing framework sit directly on top of or lip over the edges of the shower tray. Attempting to slide a tray out from underneath a fully intact cubicle will break the watertight seals, damage the surrounding tiles, and potentially shatter the glass panels."
Answered on 8th Oct 2026 - Member since Oct 2026 -
"Yes it is possible in some cases it all depends on the installation and the area surrounding"
Answered on 8th Oct 2026 - Member since Jun 2023 -
"Unfortunately the enclosure will have to removed and then reinstalled, as long as the initial installer has not siliconed the profiles to the wall."
Answered on 11th Oct 2026 - Member since Sep 2026 -
"Yes it can but it all depends on the make and model"
Answered on 12th Oct 2026 - Member since Sep 2026 -
"first of all, the shower glass must be removed and the shower enclosure must be removed and replaced with a new one, otherwise the glass will be scarce"
Answered on 13th Oct 2026 - Member since Oct 2026 -
Find Tradespeople, compare up to 3 quotes!
It's FREE and there are no obligations
Ask a Trade
Got a question that only a tradesperson can answer? We have thousands of trades ready to answer any question you may have.
Ask your question
Ask a Trade

Are you looking for advice on a DIY project or have a question for our tradespeople?

We'll email your question to tradespeople who are skilled in your chosen category.

Your question will be made public - please do not include any personal details.

{{ first(ask.errors)[0] }}

Checking your question…

By continuing you agree to the Community Guidelines.

Ready to get a price for your home improvement project?
Get started

Over 1 million homeowners and over 50,000 tradespeople
use MyJobQuote nationwide each year