Should old render be removed ?

I’ve had a couple of quotes for silicone render. One contractor has said all the old render needs to be removed first back to brick, with the possibility that lead flashing to flat roof may fall out ( it’s only been installed a couple of weeks ago) the other contractor has said that he will only remove the blown old render before applying the new 3 layer silicone render (base coat, mesh & silicone). Which approach is correct?

Asked by Jean on 19th Jun 2026
Expert Trade Answers
"I would recommend when re Rendering a house . To remove all existing Rendering. So its a new sub base on brickwork before. New canvas so to speak. Obviously the lead work. Would then be loose depending on how secure it is. In the first instance. Going over the top of old Rendering could lead to sub base issues. Such as blown render if does not bond correctly to it. Even if walls are sealed correctly. Thats my advise."
Answered on 19th Jun 2026 - Member since Sep 2023 - report
"you should go with the full strip back, buy cheap pay twice"
Answered on 22nd Jun 2026 - Member since Oct 2025 - report
"Although i agree with sts. It is possible providing the old render is straight and isnt blown (hollow sound when you knock it) meaning it has come away from the orginal base. I dont see an issue with applying the mesh and silicone render to a solid base as you can save money time and hassle.

The down side is it will bring your reveals out and could negatively effect the overall finish and alsl inconvenience the person doing the job"
Answered on 19th Jun 2026 - Member since Jun 2026 - report
"You would only have to remove render if it was blown if solid would be fine to go over once primed"
Answered on 2nd Jul 2026 - Member since Mar 2026 - report
"Blown silicone render can be repaired but I would want them to guarantee that it will work. Repairs to this type of render are not easy if it is only a small area should be fine. I hope this has helped in making your decision
Peter
Cordell Renovations"
Answered on 19th Jun 2026 - Member since Sep 2025 - report
"Hi any plasters will say this as needed but you can silicone on top of the render as silicone will cover easily and be a protective surface"
Answered on 24th Jul 2026 - Member since Aug 2016 - report
"If you applying silicone rendering you don't need to remove existing render to brickwork"
Answered on 23rd Jun 2026 - Member since May 2024 - report
"If the render is damaged or de laminating from the wall of the property it will need to be removed before Rendering. Alternatively if the render is sound there is no damp or mould you can use the EWI system using insulation boards with 2 fixings to hold in place a chemical fix and a mechanical fix. Once the existing Rendering is covered it can be basecoated and meshed then silicon top coat to finish, the render doesn't always need to be removed."
Answered on 4th Jul 2026 - Member since Nov 2025 - report
"Hi

If your going to go for silicone render the whole lot of old render needs to come off back to brick/blank canvas and be re done with the new silicone system completely. Its not the sort of product or finish you can just apply to a few blown bits of render. Ive seen people do it in the past and its always the same un happy result.

Hope this helps, have a great day"
Answered on 2nd Aug 2026 - Member since Jul 2026 - report
"The fella who to remove the blown render. But if its that bad then yes take it all off."
Answered on 21st Jun 2026 - Member since Jan 2025 - report
Find Tradespeople, compare up to 3 quotes!
It's FREE and there are no obligations
Ask a Trade
Got a question that only a tradesperson can answer? We have thousands of trades ready to answer any question you may have.
Ask your question
Ask a Trade

Are you looking for advice on a DIY project or have a question for our tradespeople?

We'll email your question to tradespeople who are skilled in your chosen category.

Your question will be made public - please do not include any personal details.

{{ first(ask.errors)[0] }}

By continuing you agree to the Community Guidelines.

Report Content

{{ first(reportForm.errors) }}

Thank you

Your report has been created and will be investigated shortly.

Ready to get a price for your home improvement project?
Get started

Over 1 million homeowners and over 50,000 tradespeople
use MyJobQuote nationwide each year